Five Islands Lobster Co

Five Islands Lobster Co. – Georgetown, Maine

Overview

Often called one of the most scenic lobster shacks in all of Maine, Five Islands Lobster Co. sits on a working fishing pier overlooking Sheepscot Bay and the rugged Five Islands just offshore. This no-frills seafood shack serves up ultra-fresh lobster, steamers, and chowder, caught right from the docks behind it. Expect prices ranging from $20–$40, depending on the size of your lobster or whether you add a full dinner plate.

Why Visit

• Jaw-dropping views of pine-clad islands and lobster boats bobbing in the harbor
• Lobsters don’t get fresher—straight from the dock to your plate
• Outdoor picnic seating with 360° coastal scenery
• Worth the drive for the remote, untouched atmosphere

What to Try

• Boiled Lobster: Served simply with drawn butter and a view
• Lobster Roll: Overflowing, lightly dressed, and unpretentious
• Fried Haddock Sandwich: Light, crispy, and a solid non-lobster choice
• Clam Chowder: Creamy and packed with flavor

Insider Tips

• Cash is king, though cards are accepted—it’s still a good idea to bring both
• No alcohol served, but you can BYOB if you keep it low-key
• Open-air seating only—bring a blanket or jacket for chilly coastal air
• Try to time your visit around sunset—the golden light over the bay is unbeatable

Nearby Attractions

• Reid State Park: Great for beachcombing, picnics, and swimming nearby
• Georgetown Island coastal drives: Stunning scenery and peaceful roads
• Morse Mountain Preserve: Hike to a secluded beach for a post-lobster stroll